You Bought Circle.

Let's Make It Yours.

Hi friend! New here?
Pour a coffee. We saved you a seat.

Community Reports: The 5 Every Owner Should Run

Share this Post:

Meet Rachel

I help creators and founders build memberships and digital businesses on Circle, and I write here about what's actually working.

Learn More

Lately my team and I have been running workflow reports for our clients, and it has been a little shocking.

Not because anybody did anything wrong. These are smart founders with beautiful communities. But pull up every active workflow and look at what it’s actually doing, and you find things. A filter catching the wrong people. A welcome email still inviting new members to a call that stopped months ago. A workflow pointing people at a space that got renamed or archived.

Nobody knew, because nobody had looked.

So here are the five community reports every owner should be running, what each one tells you, how often, and what to do with what you find.

Why Does Nobody Run These Reports?

Three reasons, and none of them is laziness. It feels like homework, the information lives in five different places, and underneath that, sometimes you don’t want to know.

You built the community so you could be with your people, not so you could stare at a dashboard. Reports feel like the vegetables of community building. You know they’re good for you, but you’d rather have the bread.

Then there’s where the information lives. Some of it’s in your analytics, some in your member list, some in your workflows, some in your events, and some of it is only in your head.

And the honest one. If you look, you might find out the welcome sequence you were proud of is broken, or that the people who joined in September never came back after day two.

Here’s how I want you to think about it instead. A report isn’t a grade, it’s a flashlight. It doesn’t tell you whether you’re good at this, it tells you where to look. The founders with the steadiest, longest-lasting communities aren’t the ones who never have problems. They’re the ones who find the problems while they’re still small.

Which Reports Should Every Community Owner Run?

Five: your active workflow audit, engagement, quiet members, new member activation, and event RSVPs against attendance. Each one answers a question you can’t answer by feel.

Your active workflow audit

A workflow is a set of instructions you wrote on one particular day, based on how your community looked that day. Then you renamed a space, moved your weekly call from Thursday to Tuesday, launched a tier, retired another. Every one of those was a good decision. The workflows didn’t get the memo, so they’re still doing exactly what you told them for a community that doesn’t exist anymore.

So pull a list of every workflow currently switched on and what each one does. Active ones only, not the bulk actions you ran once to tag a group back in March.

What to look for:

  • The filters. Who is this catching? Is it who you meant? Filters go sideways fastest, especially after you add an offer or an access group.
  • The content. Read every email and message these send, out loud if you can stand it. Is the call still on Thursdays? Is that link still good? Does it sound like you, or the version of you from two launches ago?
  • The destinations. Which spaces, access groups, and tags are these pointing at? Do they still exist, and are they still right?
  • The overlap. Two workflows doing almost the same job, so a new member gets two welcome emails, or two tags, or lands in a space they were never meant to see.

Run it quarterly at minimum, and always before a promotion, because if you’re running a sale this season, new people are about to walk into whatever’s broken. Fix the filters first, since those decide who gets what, then the content, then the overlap. Then write down what each workflow is for, so next time this takes ten minutes instead of an afternoon.

Engagement

Not the total number of posts and comments this month. That number can look great and tell you almost nothing, because 40 comments from four people is a completely different community than 40 comments from thirty.

What to look for:

  • Who’s contributing. How many different members posted, commented, or reacted this month, against how many members you have.
  • Where it’s happening. Which spaces are carrying the whole community, and which haven’t had a real conversation in weeks.
  • Who started the conversations. You every time, or members too?

That last one matters most. If every thread starts with you, you don’t have a community yet. You have an audience with a comment section, which is a perfectly fine place to be. It’s just worth knowing which one you have.

Run it monthly. If one or two spaces are doing all the work, ask whether the quiet ones need a clearer purpose or need to go, because fewer spaces with real conversation always feel warmer than a lot of spaces that feel like an empty hallway. If it’s all you starting things, pick one member this month and invite her to start a thread. Just one.

Quiet members

The people who haven’t logged in, posted, or shown up in 30 days or more. The trick is sorting them by how long they’ve been a member, because a quiet member who joined last week is a completely different situation than one who’s been with you two years.

The new one probably got lost. Something in the first few days didn’t land and they never found their footing. The long-timer might be busy, might be quietly getting ready to cancel, or might be one of those members who reads everything, never says a word, and loves it.

Run it monthly, look for patterns (did a group go quiet after the same event or the same change you made), then reach out personally. Not a mass email that says we miss you with a sad face. A real note that says something specific: “I saw you joined in September. What made you sign up? I’d love to point you to the right spot.” That one message does more than a whole re-engagement campaign. If you have a community manager or a VA, hand them the list and a few message starters in your voice.

New member activation

Everyone who joined in the last 30 days, and one simple question: they paid, but did they actually arrive?

Look at the steps you want every new member to take. Did they finish onboarding, introduce themselves, complete their profile, come to an event, post or comment? Then find where people drop off, because there’s almost always one step where a lot of them stop.

That drop-off point is the most useful thing in the report. When we run this for clients it’s almost never at the end. It’s at the very beginning: the first step asks too much, or it isn’t clear what to do, or the member lands somewhere they feel like they’ve walked into the middle of someone else’s conversation.

Run it monthly and after every promotion, because when a group joins at once you want to know within a week or two whether they’re settling in, not three months later when renewals come up. Then fix that step: easier, clearer, or more inviting. And make sure it’s automated, because if you’re tagging new members or sending welcomes one at a time manually, that’s a workflow waiting to happen.

Event RSVPs against attendance

For each event, how many RSVP’d and how many showed up. A gap is normal. Everyone RSVPs with the best intentions and then life happens. But when the gap gets big, it’s telling you something.

Maybe it’s the time of day, and if half your members are on the West Coast while your calls are at 9:00 AM Eastern, that’s not a motivation problem. Maybe it’s the reminders, and people RSVP’d three weeks ago and forgot it existed. Or maybe the title sounds great and the experience doesn’t feel worth rearranging a day for.

Run it after every event series, or quarterly, then move the time, tighten the reminders, or rethink the format. And look at who comes every single time, because those are your people. Ask what they love about it, then make more of that.

How Do You Actually Pull These Reports?

With what you already have, and you don’t need all of it. Circle analytics covers a good chunk of engagement, segments and filters find your quiet and newest members, your workflow list shows everything active, and your events show RSVPs and attendance.

If you’re using Circle AI, you can ask for a lot of this directly in plain language. And if you’re using Claude with the Circle MCP, it can look across all of it at once, pull the patterns together, and hand you a report you can read over coffee.

That’s what our Report and Audit Pack does, and it’s one of the days in our 5 Days of Community Goodies, November 23 to 27, with one goodie dropping each day at 7:00 AM and open for 24 hours. The pack is a set of skills that runs these reports for you, including the engagement report and the workflow audit we just walked through. You install them into Claude, they’re customized to your community, and the setup walks you through every step. Instead of spending an afternoon pulling numbers together, you ask, and you get a clear report back with what’s working, what needs attention, and what to do next. Not more data. Better decisions, faster. Get on the Build Notes list to know when each one goes live.

If you’d like to try a skill before that opens, our Circle Tag Cleanup skill is free right now. It goes through every member tag in your community and gives you a plan for what to keep, rename, merge, or retire, which is a great place to start if your tags are anything like most communities I see.

You Can’t Hold What You Can’t See

Most of us run our communities on feel, and feel matters. You know your people better than any report ever will.

But feel can’t tell you that a filter broke in August, or that 11 people joined last month and never made it past the welcome post, or that your Thursday call has 40 RSVPs and six faces. The reports can, and once you know, you can do something about it. Usually something small: a fixed filter, a rewritten email, a personal note to someone who got lost. Small fixes found early are what keep a community steady for years.

Here’s the other thing nobody tells you. It gets easier every time. The first workflow audit takes a while because you’re finding everything that drifted over the last year or two. The second takes a fraction of that. By the third, a cup of coffee. Same with your quiet members: the first list might be long and sting a little, but once you check it monthly it never gets that long again. You catch people at week three instead of month six. That’s the real gift here. Not the numbers, the rhythm.

So pick one report this week. Just one. If you’re running a promotion this season, make it the workflow audit, before new members walk in the door. If not, start with your quiet members. Pull the list, sort it by how long they’ve been with you, and send three personal notes. I promise you’ll learn something.

The whole point of building a community is holding the people inside it, and you can’t hold what you can’t see. Turn on the flashlight, look around a little, then go fix the one thing that’s been quietly sending your people the wrong way.

Listen to the Episode

Apple Podcasts | Spotify

If this one gave you something to work with, leave a review and hit subscribe. New episodes drop every Tuesday, and reviews are how other community builders find the show.

Subscribe on Apple Podcasts

Follow on Spotify

Watch This One

5 Reports Every Community Owner Should Run (Most Don’t)

More like it on Your Community Strategist, new every Thursday.

More Like This

Listen:How to Keep Your Community Warm Through the Holidays (While You Actually Rest). The episode this one follows, on letting your workflows carry onboarding while you rest.

Watch:Circle Member Tags Explained. Set up the tags your workflows apply automatically, so nothing gets done manually.

Listen:Don’t Dilute Your Membership (My Black Friday Rethink). What to offer instead of a discount, and the step people skip after someone buys.

Keep Going

coCreator Society is where community builders and membership founders work through this together, with the templates, the walkthroughs, and people who are one step ahead of you. Join coCreator Society

If you would rather not do this part alone, Rachel and the team build, migrate, and run communities for founders who need it done properly the first time. Talk to the team

Grab the free resources

Get Build Notes every Tuesday

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Meet Rachel

I help creators and founders build memberships and digital businesses on Circle, and I write here about what's actually working.

Learn More

Elsewhere:

ShopMy Faves

On Youtube

My Substack

Looking for something specific? Select a popular category or enter your search query below.

Read the latest

Read The Blog

Watch Now

Learn On YouTube

Grab Freebies

Fill Your Basket

Binge Now

Listen To The Podcast