It’s the night before day one. Half the lesson videos are recorded, the day three worksheet is in a doc you can’t find, and nobody has written the email that’s supposed to go out at 8:00 AM.
The idea was never the problem. The plan was.
When I ran a 14-day challenge in my own community, I built the whole thing on paper before a single lesson went live. Here’s how to run a challenge in Circle the same way: the goals, the day-by-day plan, the content, the promotion, and the setup that releases it all on schedule.
What Do You Need to Decide Before You Plan a Challenge?
Decide the name, the length, the dates, the goal, the audience, and the offer it leads to. Those six answers shape every lesson, email, and metric that comes after.
I start every challenge with a one-page overview. For The Event Edit Challenge, it read like this:
- Length: 14 days, with a fixed start and end date
- Goal: grow my newsletter list for future sales
- Audience: Circle community builders
- Main offer: my membership
That goal line does more work than it looks like. A challenge built to grow a list gets planned, promoted, and measured differently from one built to sell a seat in a paid program.
If you’re still deciding whether yours should be free or paid, or how long it should run, start with how to create a community challenge and come back here for the build.
Which Metrics Should You Track for a Community Challenge?
Track five: completion rate, community growth, engagement, conversion, and audience growth. Give each one a target, a way to measure it, and a status.
Here’s what each one tells you:
- Completion rate: how many people who started actually finished
- Community growth: new members inside your community
- Engagement: how much people are posting, replying, and participating
- Conversion: how many people took the offer the challenge leads to
- Audience growth: your wider reach, like your newsletter list and social following
Community growth and audience growth get mixed up a lot, and I’ve been asked about the difference. Community growth is people joining your community. Audience growth is everyone else you can reach, which for this challenge was the whole point.
For each goal, I track how I’m measuring it, the target, and where it stands: on track, in progress, or below target. My community growth goal was measured by new members, with a target of 100. When I recorded the walkthrough, it was at 39.
That goal is still marked in progress on purpose. The challenge now lives on as an evergreen product, so the number keeps moving long after the live dates ended.
How Do You Map Out Each Day of the Challenge?
Lay out your milestones first: one line per day on what that day accomplishes. Keep it top level. The videos and worksheets come later and hang off these milestones.
This is the skeleton, not the content. You’re answering one question for each day: what does someone walk away with?
I set mine up so I could see it two ways, as a calendar and as a list. The calendar shows how the two weeks flow. The list is faster when you’re checking what’s missing.
If you’re stuck on what each day should ask of people, how to structure a community challenge walks through the arc from day one to the finish.
How Do You Plan Challenge Content Without Losing Track?
Brain dump every piece of content first, then assign each one to a day and tie it to a milestone. You end up with one list that shows what to make and when it’s due.
Start with a brain dump
Get every idea out of your head before you sort anything. Order comes second.
What that looks like:
- List every video, guide, PDF, checklist, workshop, and exercise you might want
- Backfill which day each piece lands on
- Give each one a deadline so you’re never recording the night before
Tie every piece to a milestone
Every piece of content connects back to one of the daily milestones. So I know the video I made goes out on day one, and so does everything else that belongs to it.
When it’s time to load everything into Circle, the scheduling is already decided. You’re just placing things.
Move it through a pipeline
Each piece moves through the same stages: brain dump, creating, editing, ready, scheduled. You can see at a glance what’s stuck.
This is also where batching pays off. I create in batches wherever I can, and I did a whole episode on batch work because it changed how my work weeks run.
Why Should Challenge Promotion Have Its Own Calendar?
Because promotion is a second body of work. The daily emails, check-ins, DMs, and follow-up surveys all need writing, and they get forgotten when they’re buried in the content plan.
The way I think about it: the content is the meat. It’s what participants came for. Everything that nudges them to actually show up and consume it is promotion, even after they’ve signed up.
My promotional calendar held:
- A daily email letting people know new content was available
- Check-ins posted in the companion community
- How’s-it-going emails partway through
- Follow-up surveys
- DMs and social media posts
I kept all the swipe copy in the same dashboard, so on the day I needed an email or a post, I grabbed it and moved on. Keeping content and promotion separate works well for my brain, and it means neither one quietly slips.
For what to do with that promotion before launch and after the last day, promoting your challenge and using the results goes deeper.
How Do You Set Up a Challenge in Circle?
Build a course space with one section per day, drip each section at the same time every morning, and pair it with a separate community space where participants can talk.
Build the course space as drip content
Each section is a day, and the lessons underneath are that day’s challenge.
What that looks like:
- Make day one a little heavier to build excitement (mine had videos, exercises, and a template)
- Set every section to release at the same time; mine opened at 8:00 AM each day, starting September 1
- Let future days show as locked, so participants can see what’s coming without jumping ahead
Decide where the daily email comes from
Circle can send an email when a drip section releases. You toggle it on in the course settings and edit the text.
I still send mine through Flodesk. My freebies and audience-building all live there, and I want every email to look and feel the same. If you don’t have that setup, Circle’s built-in option does the job.
Add a companion community space
Pair the course with a separate space where participants talk about what they’re working on and find the challenge resources.
That combination worked better than I expected. I’ve left the space open for people who take the challenge now. It’s quiet since the live run ended, which is normal. It’s there when someone new needs it.
Try This Prompt
If your challenge is still a pile of ideas, this turns it into a plan you can build from.
“I’m planning a [number]-day challenge for [who it’s for] inside my Circle community. The goal is [the goal] and it leads to [the offer]. Here’s my brain dump of every content idea I have: [paste list]. Based on the approach in this post, give me one milestone per day, assign each content piece to a day and milestone, and list the promotional pieces I’ll need to write, like daily emails, check-ins, and follow-up surveys. Give me the output as a table with columns for day, milestone, content, and promotion.”
It drafts the plan. You decide what each day actually asks of your people.
A Challenge Plan Pays You Back Twice
The first payback is the live run. You’re not scrambling, because every piece already has a day, a deadline, and a place to go.
The second is everything after. When I want to relaunch, add a new twist, or run something new, every goal, lesson, and email is already laid out for me to review.
Running this one also changed how I structure things inside my community. A course with a companion space is now a setup I reach for on purpose.
The challenge is 14 days. The plan is what you keep.
The Notion template I used has a free version, the Challenge Blueprint Starter, with the goal planning and milestone mapping pages ready to fill in.
Watch the Video
New videos go up every Thursday on Your Community Strategist.
Watch This One
More like it on Your Community Strategist, new every Thursday.
More Like This
Listen: How to Create a Community Challenge That Works. The goal setting and free versus paid decision that comes before any of this planning.
Watch: Challenge Anatomy: Designing a Community Challenge That Actually Works. What each day of the challenge should ask of people, once your milestones are mapped.
Listen: From Launch to Legacy: Promoting Your Challenge & Leveraging Results. The promotion side, before launch and after the last day.
Listen: Batch Like a Boss: 10 Strategies to Supercharge Your Workflow. The batching habit that makes a 14-day content calendar doable.
Keep Going
coCreator Society is where community builders and membership founders work through this together, with the templates, the walkthroughs, and people who are one step ahead of you. Join coCreator Society
If you would rather not do this part alone, Rachel and the team build, migrate, and run communities for founders who need it done properly the first time. Talk to the team
Comments +
Comments